ModRetro Chromatic Review: The Perfect Game Boy Restomod

9.0/ 10
SCORE

ModRetro Chromatic Review

Pros

• Beautiful screen
• Sturdy construction
• Vibrant design and colors

Cons

• Batteries
• Delicate paint job
• Price
• Mono sound

Lots of brands attempt to market nostalgia, but few succeed in capturing its warm essence. From hot pink flip phones to guitar amp-inspired Bluetooth speakers, these retro callbacks have the sheen of decades prior but are nothing more than reskinned modern tech. The ModRetro Chromatic, a modern Game Boy from Oculus Rift inventor and co-founder of defense company Anduril Industries Palmer Luckey, however, makes deliberate old-school compromises. Mainly, it uses less pixel-dense LCD displays to elicit emotions from yesteryear. It’s these forced compromises that help the Chromatic stand out even if, on paper, it doesn’t have all the most cutting-edge tech. 

The result is a super-premium, slightly hindered Game Boy clone that feels like what Nintendo would have made if cost weren’t an issue. It even includes a copy of Tetris, like the original Game Boy did in 1989, a nice touch by ModRetro. The Chromatic’s high-end materials and features do come at a high price, though: $200, which is substantially higher than the Game Boy Color’s MSRP of $80 back in 1998 — about $160 adjusted for inflation. For the gamer who appreciates high-quality bespoke hardware and a commitment to authenticity, however, the price is well worth it. 

Big chunky pixels

The most standout feature on the ModRetro Chromatic is its screen. It’s a 160×144, 2.56-inch IPS LCD display. If that resolution and size seem small, that’s because they are. Unlike modern displays, which have resolutions so high that you can’t even make out the individual blocks, ModRetro keeps things chunky.

This choice allows ModRetro to re-create that original Game Boy experience. Back then, cheap consumer displays weren’t as advanced and had pixels that were simply larger and more visible. For games that used sprites, like Pokemon or Wario Land 3, the pixel layout was a perfect grid to lay art assets on. It was a limitation of the time that game creators used as a canvas. 

Modern emulation devices, including emulator apps you can install on your phone, can simply upscale all the in-game assets to make the image look super sharp. This is an approach that 2021’s Analogue Pocket used. When I heard that ModRetro was going to produce a device with big, blocky pixels, I was left perplexed. I believed that Analogue’s approach was the most sound. But after using the Chromatic, I realized there’s a charm to keeping things old school. 

In my roughly 20 hours of Pokemon Crystal and Tetris gameplay over the past few months, I was slowly won over to the charms of the Chromatic’s screen. The lower resolution is what Pokemon was meant to look like. Sure, the Analogue Pocket, as well as a whole host of other emulation devices, can mimic the retro grid of the original Game Boy using filters, but it’s not the same. You can tell it’s software making the pixels look chunky. 

In terms of colors, the IPS display ModRetro has sourced for the Chromatic is excellent. Visuals pop, and the overall presentation is clean without any smearing. The only way it could have been better is if ModRetro had opted for an OLED display. The glass atop the display is also of remarkable quality, using Sapphire crystal glass. Sapphire is a high-quality and expensive material known for its durability and transparency. It’s most often found on the faces of high-end watches and camera lenses. 

The Chromatic captures in my mind the rose-tinted memories I had of playing my Game Boy Color on long road trips back when I was in elementary school. It’s something that the Analogue Pocket couldn’t do. Although the Pocket does have a Nintendo Switch-like dock and lets me play games on my giant television, a novelty I very much enjoy.

The Chromatic feels substantial

There’s been a long-running meme about the indestructible nature of the Nokia 3310, a beloved classic cellphone from the year 2000. It was made with chunky plastic and could survive just about any drop. The original Game Boy and Game Boy Color had that same design philosophy in mind, with one even surviving the Gulf War. The minimalist iPhone style hadn’t yet entered mass-market electronic design.

The ModRetro Chromatic adopts the ’80s and ’90s chunky design philosophy and opts for magnesium alloy instead of plastic, which offers both durability and heft. The three AA batteries inside also add to the weight and feel, but bring back ’90s handheld annoyances. A set of AA batteries lasts about 6 to 8 hours, depending on the screen’s brightness. As someone who loves the Game Boy Color, one thing I don’t miss is looking under seat cushions for batteries. 

After some delay, the rechargeable battery pack is now available for $30.

Despite the shortcomings of AA batteries, as I mentioned previously, the Chromatic feels like what Nintendo would have made if costs weren’t a concern. It’s something I love about it. So rarely do we see electronics leaning into absurdity with little worry about cost. The expenditure in developing the display is something Luckey spoke of on X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter.

Even though there’s a good heft to the Chromatic, there didn’t seem to be any room for stereo speakers. Regrettably, there’s just a single speaker at the bottom of the device. A large part of the Game Boy library actually does support stereo sound, so headphones will be required to get the full sonic experience. There’s no Bluetooth either, so you’ll need to stick to wired cans. 

Vibrant but delicate paint job

The ModRetro Chromatic is almost the antithesis of the Analogue Pocket. It opts for metals over plastics. It sports a lower-res screen over one that’s literally 14 times more dense. And instead of black or white, it gives consumers a wide range of color options, all with wonderful flourishes to give each unit a distinct identity. A few weeks back, all colors, except the muted GameStop-exclusive gray were sold out. Now, all colors are back in stock, including a new Cloud color scheme, which is white with purple accents.

(Note: Analogue has done limited edition re-releases of the Pocket in a wide range of colors, including ones inspired by the original Game Boy Color and Game Boy Pocket lineups, as well as a $500 aluminum variant.)

Our first-edition review unit in yellow, which ModRetro calls Volt, has red face buttons and brown and beige accents in the corners, reminding me of the earth tones present in homes from the 1970s. The ModRetro Chromatic is as much a plaything as it is a display piece. 

Unfortunately, ModRetro didn’t spray a clear coat over the Chromatic’s luscious paint job. Sure, it gives the Chromatic a satisfying matte texture, but it makes the paint very delicate. Even with my careful use, I’ve already marred it with two small nicks, revealing the bare metal underneath. It makes me scared to take the Chromatic out of my house, which defeats the purpose of handheld gaming. 

A worthy Game Boy revival at a high price

The ModRetro Chromatic’s gorgeous screen, magnesium build, stand-out paint job and sapphire crystal were introduced at a $200 price. That is, at the time this review was first published, it was $200. Now, if you want a Chromatic with sapphire crystal, it’ll cost $300. Thankfully, there’s still a $200 option fitted with Gorilla Glass, meaning it’s not as strong but is still scratch resistant. Either way, that’s a lot to pay for an electronic that can only play games from the ’80s, ’90s and early 2000s. However, ModRetro is publishing newer Game Boy games, and companies like Incube8 Games, Bitmap Soft, and Mega Cat Studios are also releasing newer as well as homebrew titles on classic cartridges.

For $200, you could get a Nintendo Switch Lite and gain access to a massive library of modern titles as well as older games via the Nintendo Switch Online service. There’s also a slew of emulation devices filling up Amazon, AliExpress and TikTok Shop that offer thousands of old-school preloaded Game Boy titles of legally dubious origin for less than $50.

Here’s the thing: Emulation can’t beat the original. Even on the newly released Nintendo Switch 2, game emulation of older content still introduces input lag, which is the amount of time it takes for a button press to show up on screen. For hard-core gamers, this is suboptimal. Only when the original code is running through real circuits and transistors does it deliver an authentic experience. 

If you’re the type that doesn’t care about authenticity and a true-to-form gaming experience, well, you likely aren’t reading this review. For this person, one of those emulation handhelds will suffice. There are dedicated sites that review the sea of retro gaming handhelds coming out of China, seemingly on a bi-weekly basis.

But if you’re the person who wants the satisfying snap of docking in an old-school Game Boy cartridge and sinking into the corner cushions of your couch with a pouch of Capri Sun resting on your chest, there really isn’t a much better experience than what the ModRetro Chromatic offers.