Carrying a luxury handbag used to be a reference to elevated uber-rich status, great style sense, and the “have it, flaunt it” attitude. However, with changing times and a few iconic handbag brands that have risen to legendary status, buying luxury is more about buying an asset than a fashion splurge.
At the top of that elite list? Hermès. In fact, Hermès was the only luxury brand to report profits in 2024, reinforcing its unmatched prestige and resilience in a volatile market. And when it comes to Hermès handbags, no debate is more iconic—or more engrossing—than Birkin vs. Kelly.
Crafted with precision and dripping in exclusivity, the Birkin and Kelly aren’t just statements of luxury—they’re alternative assets that have outperformed traditional investments like gold, stocks, and even real estate.
Price Hikes & Prestige: Why Hermès Just Made These Bags Even More Coveted
Hermès quietly raised prices again in 2025—some regions saw up to 10% increases, especially for popular models like the Birkin 25 and Kelly Sellier. While this may have been a shock to the boutiques, for savvy collectors and resale investors, it was music to the ears.
Why? Because every price hike:
- Elevates the entry point for future buyers, making pre-owned bags a more attractive option.
- Increases scarcity—people hold onto their Hermès bags longer, driving resale competition.
- Strengthens brand prestige, which keeps demand high and inventory low.
Translation: If you already own one, you’re sitting on an appreciating asset. If you’re thinking of buying one, the sooner, the better—especially if you’re eyeing rare colors or sizes.
So, which bag should you bet on—Hermès Birkin or Hermès Kelly? How do you pick the one that is perfect for you? Should you go for better resale value, higher return on investment, or the timeless appeal needed to complete your wardrobe?
Time to decode each aspect in detail.
What Birkin and Kelly Have in Common
- Meticulous craftsmanship
- Hermès’ hallmark saddle stitching
- Lock and key closure
- Classic leathers like Togo, Epsom, and Box
- Sky-high resale value if properly cared for
Both are timeless, coveted, and guaranteed to turn heads.
Their Differences
1. Design Differences: Structure, Size & Style
Hermès Birkin Bag
- Features a relaxed, open-top design (with flap).
- Two handles for handheld carry.
- No shoulder strap.
- The roomy interior makes it ideal for travel or daily wear.
- Exudes power and prestige.
Hermès Kelly Bag
- Structured and more formal, with a trapezoid silhouette.
- Comes with a single top handle and a detachable shoulder strap.
- Offers versatility—perfect for both day and evening.
- Available in two finishes—Sellier (structured, sharp) and Retourne (softer, casual).
For buyers searching for the “best Hermès bag for everyday use,” the Kelly wins in terms of practicality and hands-free options; for those looking for a statement piece, Birkin is the one.
2. A Tale of Two Icons: The History Behind Birkin & Kelly
A handbag’s storytelling power often influences its perceived value, especially in niche collector circles, and these two are stitched into Hermès’ heritage.
The Birkin
Introduced in 1984 for actress Jane Birkin following a happy accident. When Jane Birkin spilled her belongings mid-flight beside Jean-Louis Dumas, then CEO of Hermès. The bag was designed to blend both fashion and function. It became the ultimate symbol of quiet luxury, often carried by celebrities, business elites, and collectors.
The Kelly
The Kelly was born in the 1930s as the Sac à dépêches but shot to fame in 1956 when Grace Kelly famously used it to shield her pregnancy from paparazzi. Since then, it’s been the epitome of old-school glamour and feminine elegance, seen as the perfect blend of style and sophistication.
3. Exclusivity & Availability: The Hermès Hurdle
Both bags are notoriously difficult to buy at Hermès boutiques. You can’t just walk in and pick one off a shelf. Sales associates offer both bags to approved clients, usually after they spend significantly on other items.
- Birkin bags are harder to score due to slightly lower production and higher global demand. They are often tied to “purchase history” with Hermès.
- Kelly bags, while still exclusive, are considered marginally more accessible.
- The mini Kelly (especially the Kelly 20) is currently among the most in-demand bags on the market.
The quickest way to “how to buy a Birkin bag” or “where to find an authentic Kelly bag” often leads shoppers to trusted pre-owned luxury marketplaces like The Luxury Closet.
Why Is the Birkin More Expensive Than the Kelly?
It’s not just hype. The Birkin’s larger size, extra materials, and more labor-intensive construction contribute to the price. Add in its aura of exclusivity and higher demand in global luxury markets, and you’ve got a bag that often fetches five to six figures—even pre-owned.
4. Resale Value & Market Trends: What the Numbers Say
If we’re talking cold, hard resale numbers, the Birkin tends to lead, especially in larger sizes and exotic skins. It’s also historically more liquid—easier to sell fast at a premium.
According to luxury resale data:
- The Birkin bag investment value can go up 14% per year, depending on rarity, color, and material.
- A Togo leather Birkin 30 in classic colors like Etoupe or Black consistently ranks among the top reselling bags in the world.
But the Kelly—particularly in mini sizes—has seen explosive appreciation, and its recent demand spike shows no signs of slowing.
- Some Kelly bags—especially the Mini Kelly or Sellier style—have appreciated over 200% in recent years.
- Exotic leathers (like Himalaya crocodile) and limited-edition releases perform best in resale.
Long-term strategy? Buy the one you’ll use, love, and keep in pristine condition. That emotional connection often yields the best financial return.
Pro tip: When buying pre-owned, look for limited edition or discontinued models—they tend to perform better long-term.
5. ROI Breakdown: Which Bag Wins on Paper?
Let’s refer to hard resale data.
| Bag | Average Retail Price | Average Resale Value | Annual ROI Estimate |
| Birkin 30 Togo | $10,000–$12,000 | $13,000–$18,000 | ~12–18% |
| Kelly 25 Sellier | $9,000–$11,000 | $14,000–$20,000 | ~15–22% |
Note: Prices vary based on size, hardware, and condition.
“Which Hermès bag has the highest resale value?” The answer depends on style and rarity, but Mini Kelly bags and neutral-color Birkins top the charts.
6. Who Prefers What: Celebrity Style & Pop Culture Power
Kim Kardashian, Victoria Beckham, and Cardi B are the top celebrity fans of the Birkin. Kelly has graced the arms of Meghan Markle, Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, and Lady Gaga, proving their handbag choice mirrors their social image. Besides that, social media, especially Instagram and TikTok, have revived the Mini Kelly mania and cemented its presence among the elite.
The chances of you siding with the same bag as your favorite celebrity are pretty high!
Match the Bag to Your Life and Choices, Not Just Figures and Trends
At the end of the day, choosing between a Birkin and a Kelly isn’t just about numbers. It’s about who you are, how you move through the world, and what kind of statement you want your bag to make—quiet, loud, or somewhere in between.
Choose the bag as per your persona:
You’re the type who runs the room before you even speak.
You live in tailored blazers, you’ve got a standing reservation at your favorite hotel, and your idea of casual is still polished. The Birkin is your bag. It’s structured without being uptight, roomy enough for the essentials and the just-in-cases, and screams “I’ve arrived”—even when you don’t say a word.
You believe less is more—but make it luxury.
You don’t chase trends; you start them. You know your angles, your neutrals, and your resale potential. If you had to choose between a flashy logo and perfect proportions, you’d pick the latter every time. The Mini Kelly is basically your spirit bag: compact, covetable, and always a conversation starter.
You are imaginative and creative, a little mysterious.
You collect niche perfumes, vintage scarves, and books you’ve actually read. You want a bag that says, “I appreciate craftsmanship,” not “I need attention.” Enter the Kelly Sellier—clean lines, a little structure, and all the poise of Grace Kelly with just the right edge.
You’re on the move. Always.
School run, conference call, pilates, dinner—rinse, repeat. You need something elegant but not fussy. The Kelly Retourne (the softer, slouchier version) lets you sling it over your shoulder and get on with your day. It’s still luxury, just with a bit more oomph.
You don’t wear your wealth—you invest it.
You’ve read the market reports, know what colors sell better in Tokyo vs Dubai, and have alerts set up for rare Birkins. If you’re looking to maximize ROI, the classic Birkin—or better yet, an exotic—should be on your radar. Not for showing off, just for showing receipts (literal and financial).
You like your style and how you want your champagne: classic and timeless.
Clean lines, perfect tailoring, pearls over platforms—if that’s your vibe, the Kelly is your match. It’s refined, elegant, and never out of place—whether you’re stepping into an art gala or a candlelit bistro in Paris.
Bottom line?
Buy the bag that feels like you—not just the one trending on TikTok or topping resale charts. That connection? It shows. And funnily enough, it’s often the bags most worn with love and intention that hold the most value.
So Now, Which Hermès Bag Should You Invest In?
The Birkin is bold, attention-grabbing, and best for a maximalist or confident minimalist.
The Kelly is refined, romantic, and fits seamlessly into a curated, classic wardrobe.
There’s no wrong answer—only the one that fits your life.
- If you want flexibility + growing demand → Go for the Kelly (especially the Mini).
- If you want prestige + long-term cultural clout → Choose the Birkin.
- If ROI is your top goal → Focus on rare materials, limited editions, and trending sizes in either.
Invest Smart with The Luxury Closet
Remember: the best investment isn’t always the most expensive—it’s the one you’ll carry, love, and maybe one day, pass down. Whether you’re buying from a boutique or a resale platform, always choose authenticity, especially when it comes to Hermès.
Want to skip the waitlists and the eyewatering retail prices? The Luxury Closet is your bestie with benefits.
At The Luxury Closet, shopping for an authentic Hermès Birkin or Kelly bag is smooth, easy and quick. No waitlists—just verified luxury, global shipping, and flexible payment plans. Every Hermès bag in our collection is:
-
Authenticated by in-house experts
-
In investment-worthy condition
-
Listed with transparent pricing and resale insights
Explore our curated collection of rare, collector-grade Hermès pieces today. Who knows a pristine Hermès is waiting just for you!
Still Not Able to Make the Decision, Take the Quiz
Let the bag choose you!
Answer these five questions and tally your score to find your match.
- What’s your daily style uniform?
A. Structured, power-dressing pieces with a hint of glamour
B. Effortless classics with a dash of Parisian cool - What’s in your bag on a typical day?
A. Laptop, planner, makeup pouch, emergency heels
B. Phone, cardholder, lipstick, maybe a croissant - How do you usually carry your bag?
A. In the crook of your arm like the boss you are
B. Gracefully over the shoulder or by the handle - Your dream vacation looks like:
A. A luxe villa with private staff and spreadsheet budgeting
B. A scenic escape filled with museums, bookstores, and silk scarves - When it comes to investment:
A. ROI, resale potential, and rarity are your top filters
B. Sentimental value, wearability, and long-term elegance win
Results:
Mostly A’s – The Birkin is calling out to you!
You want your bag to mean business. You’re investing with intent, and the Birkin matches your energy—bold, substantial, and always in demand.
Mostly B’s – The Kelly is welcoming you with open arms!
Refined, timeless, and a little under-the-radar—that’s your style. The Kelly suits your pace and grace, whether it’s a Sellier for structure or Retourne for ease.
Enjoy your purchase and be proud that you could own it! Most of the world can’t.
